A former California mayor who was trusted to manage a church’s finances has admitted stealing nearly $390,000 over six years, using the money to pay for personal expenses while the congregation struggled to keep its doors open.
Tamara Le Ann Wallace, 56, the former mayor of South Lake Tahoe, pleaded guilty Thursday, October 29, to federal wire fraud in a scandal that devastated a local church, ended her political career and could now send her to prison for years.
According to federal prosecutors, Wallace began working as a part-time bookkeeper at Lake Tahoe Community Presbyterian Church in 2018. She was responsible for paying bills, monitoring the budget and maintaining financial records, giving her extraordinary access to the congregation’s money.
But behind the scenes, prosecutors say, Wallace was secretly draining the church’s accounts.
Between April 2019 and September 2025, she wrote reimbursement checks to herself for expenses she had never incurred and transferred church funds into bank accounts she controlled. To keep the scheme hidden, she falsified financial records, allowing the theft to continue for years.
The stolen money helped cover personal expenses, including rent and travel. Meanwhile, the church was pushed toward financial collapse.
Federal authorities revealed that Wallace’s actions nearly forced the congregation to shut down. Church leaders had to slash programs, take out multiple loans and pay additional interest and late fees on overdue bills, all while trying to keep the organization operating.
The scandal became public in October 2025, when Wallace made a stunning confession in an open letter to the South Lake Tahoe community. She acknowledged taking church funds over an extended period and described overwhelming guilt and shame surrounding her actions.
Wallace also disclosed that she had experienced a serious mental health crisis the previous month. Days after her public admission, she resigned from the City Council, bringing an abrupt end to her time in local government.
The case eventually drew federal investigators, with the FBI and El Dorado County District Attorney’s Office examining the financial misconduct.
Wallace initially pleaded not guilty at an October 13 court appearance, but changed her plea just over two weeks later in a Sacramento courtroom.
According to local outlet South Tahoe Now, U.S. District Judge Troy Nunley asked Wallace whether she was pleading guilty because she had committed the crime.
“I am,” she replied.
The admission marked a dramatic turning point in a case involving an elected official who had held a position of public trust while secretly taking money from a religious institution.
El Dorado County District Attorney Vern Pierson said his office pursued federal involvement because he believed the consequences should reflect the seriousness of the financial harm.
The guilty plea does not mean Wallace will receive the maximum punishment, but the stakes remain substantial. She faces up to 20 years in federal prison and a $250,000 fine, although prosecutors have indicated they will recommend a lesser sentence. Restitution is also expected to be part of the court’s decision.
Wallace is scheduled to be sentenced January 14, 2027.
For the congregation she once served, however, the damage extends beyond the missing money. A church that relied on Wallace to safeguard its finances was instead left borrowing money, cutting services and fighting to survive.
And the former mayor who once helped lead a California community is now awaiting judgment for betraying the trust of one of its local institutions.
Discover more from Next Gen News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Fraud and theft are the new national pastimes. Bring back drawing and quartering as a deterrent.
Writing your headline by beginning it with the fact this msyor is a republican leads most readers to conclude that is important. It is not. Why write this way? Obviously your writer is a democrat. Where is your objectivity.