SOURCE: @REPCONGRESSMAN MAX MILLER/ IG

A Republican congressman with close ties to President Donald Trump has suffered another devastating setback after an Ohio judge threw out his defamation lawsuit against his ex-wife, ruling that a disturbing allegation involving hot water was “substantially true.”

Rep. Max Miller, who recently lost his reelection bid in a stunning Democratic upset, was also ordered to pay $76,672.38 in legal fees and costs after a judge found no credible evidence supporting his claims against former wife Emily Moreno.

The November 13 ruling, made public Monday, November 16, marks another major blow for the embattled Ohio Republican, whose political career has been overshadowed by allegations of domestic abuse and an increasingly bitter custody battle.

The controversy erupted in May when the Daily Mail reported that Miller had allegedly thrown a pot of boiling water at Moreno during an argument at their Ohio home on June 9, 2024. According to the report, some of the water struck Moreno’s chest, leaving injuries she photographed that same day.

Miller vehemently denied the allegations and filed a defamation lawsuit against Moreno, accusing her of spreading false claims to damage his reputation, undermine his congressional campaign and gain an advantage in their custody dispute.

But an audio recording presented in court helped unravel his case.

According to Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Joy Kennedy, the recording captured Moreno confronting Miller about the incident. Although he disputed certain details, Miller acknowledged that something had happened, telling her, “it was never done to hurt you with intent.”

Kennedy determined that the recording supported the central allegation that Miller had poured or doused Moreno with hot water.

“The imputation that Plaintiff poured or doused Defendant Moreno with hot water is substantially true,” the judge wrote.

Miller had previously characterized the incident as horseplay, claiming he sprayed Moreno with water from a kitchen sink rather than throwing boiling water at her.

The judge did not determine that Miller intentionally injured Moreno or establish the precise temperature of the water. However, she concluded that his arguments failed to disprove the essential allegation underlying the news report.

The ruling also rejected Miller’s accusations that Moreno was responsible for leaking the story to the press.

Kennedy found no credible evidence that Moreno had supplied information to the Daily Mail or arranged for the allegations to be published. She also found that Miller failed to establish actual malice, the demanding legal standard public figures must meet when pursuing defamation claims.

The lawsuit was dismissed with prejudice under Ohio’s anti-SLAPP law, which provides protections against certain lawsuits targeting speech on matters of public concern. That means Miller cannot simply refile the same claims, although he can appeal the decision.

The financial consequences are substantial. Kennedy ordered the congressman to pay Moreno $76,672.38 in attorney fees and costs, turning his attempt to seek damages into an expensive legal defeat.

The ruling comes just weeks after voters delivered Miller another major rejection at the ballot box.

On November 3, Democrat Brian Poindexter defeated Miller by approximately 10 percentage points in Ohio’s 7th Congressional District, a seat Trump had carried by roughly 11 points just two years earlier.

Miller, a former Trump White House aide, had entered Congress with the president’s backing. Trump also attended his 2022 wedding to Moreno, the daughter of Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno of Ohio.

But the allegations surrounding Miller’s marriage created a political firestorm that extended well beyond the couple’s divorce. The House Ethics Committee opened an investigation into his conduct in August, while prominent Ohio Republicans, including Sen. Bernie Moreno, called for Miller to resign.

Moreno has also made other allegations of physical abuse against her former husband, which Miller has denied. Those separate accusations were not resolved by Monday’s defamation ruling.

For Miller, the latest decision compounds an extraordinary political downfall. After losing a congressional seat once considered safely Republican, the Trump ally now faces a significant legal bill and a court ruling that directly undermines a central part of his effort to challenge his ex-wife’s account.

The dismissal closes this particular case at the trial-court level, but the former couple’s broader legal battles remain unresolved.


Discover more from Next Gen News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *